The question of whether to use active voice or passive voice has been a niggling one for researchers across the globe since time immemorial. Many scholars are under the impression that the passive voice is not preferred by journals, which adhere to a certain set of style guidelines, and needs to be avoided religiously. However, this is not entirely true; the passive voice is appropriate at many places, but researchers tend to overuse it.
As such, the benefits and inadequacies of active voice and passive voice need to be placed in the public domain for researchers to come up with an informed decision. Both forms could be used in the same paper; it is a matter of selecting the right voice for what one wants to express.
Advantages of the Active Voice
The active voice presents a clear sequence of events: tiger eats deer. However, in a sentence with the passive voice, the reader has to wait until the end to figure out who was responsible for eating the deer. Besides, a passive sentence is invariably long, which could further confuse readers. In comparison, the active voice is more direct, which leads to shorter sentences. Although it is perfectly legitimate from a grammatical standpoint to have a paper with sentences of varying lengths, short sentences are comparatively easier to comprehend than long ones.
Advantages of the Passive Voice
Certain publishing manuals say that the passive voice is useful when one wants to emphasize the object rather than the subject. For example, consider the sentence: “The experiment was conducted by the researchers.”
It is very important to understand that there is no style manual that expressly prohibits the passive voice. What they underline is that both active voice and passive voice should be used judiciously to improve the expression in question.
by Chelsea Lee
Few topics in scholarly writing raise as many questions as passive voice. Many writers have gotten the impression that passive voice isn’t allowed in APA Style or that if it is allowed, it is to be avoided at all costs. However, that’s an oversimplification. The reality is that sometimes the passive voice is appropriate, but many writers overuse it.
This post will show you how to identify the passive and active voices, explain the advantages and disadvantages of each, and help you choose the appropriate voice for your writing. Both passive and active voices are likely to appear in the same paper; it is just a matter of choosing the right voice given what you want to express.
Here is the classic formula for identifying the passive voice:
A “to be” verb + a past participle + the word by.
- Active voice: The lion ate the mouse.
- Passive voice: The mouse was eaten by the lion.
In the active voice sentence, the actor (the lion) is presented first, followed by the action (eating) and then the object of that action (the mouse). In the passive voice sentence, the order is reversed.
There are two caveats to this formula:
- Sometimes the word by is left out of a passive voice sentence but is still implicit in the meaning, for example, in a sentence like “This topic was addressed in the paper.” If you can ask “by whom?” and come up with a coherent answer (such as “by the researchers” or “by Smith”), then the sentence is still in the passive voice even though the word by does not appear.
- Not all instances of to be indicate the passive voice, as in a sentence like “The participants were hungry.” Asking “hungry by whom?” makes no sense, so this sentence is not in the passive voice even though it has a to be verb.
Advantages of the Active Voice
The Publication Manual says to “prefer the active voice” (p. 77), and there are two main reasons why. First, the active voice clearly lays out the chain of events: Lion eats mouse. With a passive voice sentence, the reader must wait until the end of the sentence to discover who was responsible for the action. When used in a long sentence, the passive voice may confuse readers. Second, the active voice usually creates shorter sentences. Although your paper should include a variety of sentence lengths, shorter sentences are usually easier to understand than longer ones.
Here are two common cases in which you should prefer the active voice rather than the passive voice:
- Use the active voice to describe your own actions. It is completely permissible, and in fact encouraged, to use the first person to describe your own actions in APA Style. Use I to refer to yourself if you worked alone and we if you worked as part of a group (see PM 3.09 for more).
- Active voice: I conducted an experiment about body image.
- Passive voice: An experiment about body image was conducted.
- Use the active voice to acknowledge the participation of people in research studies, which is an important part of reporting research (see Guideline 3 on p. 73 of the Publication Manual for more on this). For example, researchers often administer surveys to participants or observe them for certain behaviors. Show with your sentences how participants completed actions, rather than how researchers acted upon them, as in these examples:
- Active voice: The students completed the surveys.
- Passive voice: The surveys were completed by the students.
Advantages of the Passive Voice
The Publication Manual also states that “the passive voice is acceptable in expository writing [writing used to give information on a topic or to explain something] and when you want to focus on the object or recipient of the action rather than on the actor” (p. 77). Here is an example of appropriate passive voice:
- First-year students have been underserved by the university administration.
In this sentence, the focus is on first-year students. Depending on the context, this may be exactly what you are going for. The active voice version (“The university administration has underserved first-year students”) puts the focus on the university administration, which is not necessarily what you want. Remember, APA Style doesn’t prohibit the passive voice; it just requires that you use it wisely.
Strategies for Choosing the Appropriate Voice
Both the active and passive voices have uses in scholarly writing, so employ them appropriately. However, newer writers especially tend to overuse the passive voice, which can lead to clumsy, long, and confusing sentences. With that in mind, we recommend the following:
- Prefer the active voice over the passive voice to create clear, concise sentences; however, remember that the passive voice can also be an appropriate choice under certain circumstances.
- Identify cases of the passive voice by looking for instances of the to be verb + a past participle + the word by.
- Try rewriting a passive voice sentence in the active voice to determine which voice more clearly communicates your ideas.
For more on this topic, see section 3.18 of the Publication Manual.
Leave a comment if you've got questions that you want to be answered by us.